Editors at AllMusic rated this album 4 out of 5 stars, with critic Jack Rabid writing that "the early Kinks could be even rawer and more exciting in BBC halls than on their known Pye Records recordings" and emphasizing the early recordings by stating that "the first 19 tracks are indispensable".[1] In The Austin Chronicle, Kent H. Benjamin gave this compilation the same score, stating that "many of the tracks substantially exceed their tinny-sounding studio counterparts, and most of the Kinks' early hits appear in sizzling, sloppy live takes that are British Invasion pop at its best".[2]Cincinnati CityBeat's Brad Quinn also states that certain tracks are superior to the album versions and points out highlights on the second disc, which he considers inferior to the first.[3] Ryan Kearney of Pitchfork Media rated this album a 6.5 out of 10, praising many early tracks, but criticizing several of the latter ones and also omissions of key Kinks songs, summing up that this is "mildly interesting" and "must be deemed worthwhile for completists only".[4] Writing in Rolling Stone, Marc Weingarten scored this release 4 out of 5 stars, and called it "an embarrassment of riches" and recommends it for new listeners to the band.[5] That publication also issued an overview of the band's work in 2019 and characterized this album as a "going deeper" album to listen to, stating that "BBC Sessions is the place to experience their prime live power" and recommended it over other live recordings.[6]
Track listing
All songs written by Ray Davies, except where noted
Disc one
interview – 0:09
"You Really Got Me" (30 October 1964 at Playhouse Theatre, London) – 2:16
interview – 1:10
"Cadillac" (Ellas McDaniel, 7 September 1964 at Playhouse Theatre, London) – 2:36
Dave Davies – lead guitar; backing vocals; lead vocals on "Wonder Where My Baby Is Tonight", "Death of a Clown", "Good Luck Charm", and "Mindless Child of Motherhood"; co-lead vocals on "Milk Cow Blues"; piano on "Get Back in the Line"
Ray Davies – rhythm guitar; lead vocals; piano on "Ev'rybody's Gonna Be Happy", "This Strange Effect", "Wonder Where My Baby Is Tonight", "The Village Green Preservation Society", and "When I Turn Off the Living Room Lights"; organ on "The Village Green Preservation Society" and "Did You See His Name?"; harmonica on "Cadillac" and "Victoria"; production on "Did You See His Name?"
John Dalton – bass guitar (November 1968 recording onward)
Pete Quaife – bass guitar and backing vocals (through July 1968 recordings)
Additional performers
John Beecham – trombone on "Here Comes Yet Another Day", "Money Talks", and "Skin and Bone"; tuba on "Mirror of Love"
Alan Black – introduction on "Victoria"
Laurie Brown – trumpet on "Here Comes Yet Another Day" and "Money Talks"
Rasa Davies – backing vocals on "Death of a Clown"
Claire Hamill – backing vocals on "Victoria", "Money Talks"
Alan Holmes – tenor saxophone on "Here Comes Yet Another Day" and "Money Talks", and "Skin and Bone"; clarinet on "Mirror of Love" and "Holiday"
Nicky Hopkins – piano on "Death of a Clown", "Harry Rag", "Good Luck Charm", and "Waterloo Sunset"; Mellotron on "Days"; organ on "Love Me Till the Sun Shines"
Maryann Price – backing vocals on "Here Comes Yet Another Day", "Money Talks"
Michael Rosen – trumpet on "Skin and Bone"
Pam Travis – backing vocals on "Here Comes Yet Another Day", "Victoria", "Money Talks"
Technical personnel
Bill Aitken – engineering on "Here Comes Yet Another Day", "Money Talks", "Mirror of Love", "Celluloid Heroes", and "Skin and Bone" / "Dry Bones"
Bernie Andrews – production on "Cadillac", "Love Me Till the Sun Shines", "Harry Rag", "Waterloo Sunset", and "Days"
Keith Bateson – production on "See My Friend", "This Strange Effect", and "Monica"
Bill Bebb – production on "Death of a Clown", "Good Luck Charm", and "The Village Green Preservation Society"
Bob Conduct – engineering on "Skin and Bone" and "Money Talks"
John Edgehill – engineering on "Demolition", production on "Victoria"
Hugh Gilmour – artwork, design
Jimmy Grant – production on "Milk Cow Blues", "Wonder Where My Baby Is Tonight", "Till the End of the Day", and "Where Have All the Good Times Gone"
Jeff Griffin – production on "Demolition", "Victoria", and "Get Back in the Line"
John Walters – production on "Skin and Bone" and "Money Talks"
Brian Wiley – production on "Milk Cow Blues", "Wonder Where My Baby Is Tonight", "Till the End of the Day", and "Where Have All the Good Times Gone"
Paul Williams – production on "Mindless Child of Motherhood"
Tony Wilson – production on "Here Comes Yet Another Day", "Money Talks", "Mirror of Love", "Celluloid Heroes", "Skin and Bone" / "Dry Bones", and "Get Back in the Line"