Israel was represented at the Eurovision Song Contest 2024 with the song "Hurricane", written by Avi Ohayon, Keren Peles, and Stav Beger, and performed by Eden Golan. The Israeli participating broadcaster, the Israeli Public Broadcasting Corporation (IPBC/Kan), selected Golan as its entrant through the show HaKokhav HaBa (Rising Star), in collaboration with commercial broadcaster Keshet and Tedy Productions, while the song "Hurricane" was internally selected. The Israel–Hamas war impacted the production of the show and brought Israel's participation in the contest into controversy.[1]
Israel was drawn to compete in the second semi-final of the Eurovision Song Contest which took place on 9 May 2024. Performing during the show in position 14, "Hurricane" was announced among the top 10 entries of the first semi-final and therefore qualified to compete in the final on 11 May. It was later revealed that Israel placed first out of the 16 participating countries in the semi-final with 194 points. In the final, Israel performed in position 6 and placed fifth out of the 25 participating countries, scoring 375 points.
As part of its duties as participating broadcaster, Kan organises the selection of its entry in the Eurovision Song Contest and broadcasts the event in the country. On 5 June 2023, Kan confirmed its participation in the 2024 contest, announcing that its representative would return to be selected through the reality singing competition Rising Star, which had been used between 2015 and 2020.[3]
Preliminary casting rounds started in late July 2023[4][5] and ended on 10 September 2023 at Pavilion 2 of Expo Tel Aviv (Eurovision 2019 venue), where candidates were judged based on an a cappella performance of two songs of their choice.[6][7]
Shows and impact of the Israel–Hamas war
Qualifiers from the preliminary casting phase proceeded to the auditions proper, held in Neve Ilan and originally set to be filmed in the presence of an audience from late September or early October 2023 and to begin airing in November 2023.[4][5][8] However, following the outbreak of the Israel–Hamas war on 7 October 2023, filming for the competition was initially postponed in compliance with the Home Front Command's protection guidelines,[8][9] eventually beginning without an audience in the week between 16 and 22 October, with the broadcasts initially scheduled to start on 31 October.[10][11][12] The audience vote, which was set to determine 40% of the result alongside the judges, was replaced by the votes of a focus group.[10][12]
On 31 October 2023, when it was planned to air, the broadcast of the first episode was postponed in order to commemorate two soldiers who had been killed in combat earlier that day.[13][14] The decision to air the show in such circumstances was criticised by Israeli audiences and media,[15][16] and the broadcasts were ultimately rescheduled to start on 20 November.[17][18] The second show, scheduled for 22 November,[19] was postponed to make room for a governmental press conference regarding a deal negotiated that day for the release of hostages held by Hamas;[20] broadcasting resumed on 2 December.[21][22] Segments from the opening of the casting round of 10 September were included in the televised shows.[6][7]
The audition shows also included segments in support of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), and the very first contestant Shai Tamino, a member of the Education and Youth Corps band, performed wearing military fatigues;[17][19] this led some Eurovision fan media outlets to begin limiting their coverage of Israel's participation in the 2024 contest, on the grounds that it clashed with the non-political and pacifist values traditionally associated with the event.[a]
Auditions
Candidates were required to get a score of at least 70% of the votes from the judges and a focus group in order to advance.
The following phase, aired in segments on 31 December 2023, consisted of a shortlisting round, where the artists receiving a "yes" vote from all six judges automatically qualified and the others were chosen among those who had received four or five "yes" votes. 14 artists were shortlisted, namely Lian Biran, Eden Golan, Arik Sinai, Yehuda Saado, Shai Tamino, Ido Bartal, Mika Moshe, Jonathan Bitton, Mika Kertis, Dor Shimon, Or Cohen, Gal Kafri, Moria Angel, and Orel Ravid.[38]
Top 14 round
In the top 14 round, the votes of the judges and an audience determined one contestant to be eliminated from each show, ultimately coming down to the top five. In each of the first two shows and in the sixth show, the artist to be eliminated was the one getting the lowest overall score. In the third, fourth, seventh and ninth show, the artists were paired in duels, with the winners directly qualifying to the next round; the judges then selected one eliminee per show among the others. In the fifth show, the artists were coupled to perform duets, with the eliminee selected between the lowest scoring duo. In the eighth show, each contestant performed a duet with a surprise guest artist.
In the first show of the semi-final, the votes of the judges and the audience determined one qualifier to the final. In the second show, the remaining four artists performed, and one of them left the competition.
The final took place on 6 February 2024 and was divided in a duel round, eliminating one finalist, and a superfinal among the remaining three artists, determining the winner. On 5 February, a special broadcast was aired featuring performances by guest artists and the finalists, each of whom announced which song they would perform in the first round of the final; a public vote, held via the Mako app and determining 10% of the results of the first round, was opened on the same day.[50]2023 Israeli representativeNoa Kirel performed as a guest during the show. In the superfinal, a 50/50 combination of jury and public votes selected Eden Golan as the winner.[51]
The song that Eden Golan would perform in the contest was internally selected by a professional committee. On 16 January 2024, Kan and Keshet opened a window for specially selected songwriters to submit their entries until 11 February; submissions were required to include lyrics in Hebrew.[52][53] Golan also had the option to submit her own entry.[51] The selected entry, titled "Hurricane", was revealed on 10 March during a special broadcast on Kan 11, aired from the Yitzhak Rabin Center in Tel Aviv and hosted by Lior Suchard.[54][55][56]
Controversy
On 19 February 2024, a report by Israel Hayom claimed that the proposed entry for the contest was being written by Avi Ohayon [he], Keren Peles, and Stav Beger, with it most likely being titled "October Rain".[57] On 21 February, Ynet claimed that the EBU had rejected the entry on the grounds of political content in its lyrics, but that Kan was not planning to change the song or its content.[58] Kan and the EBU later addressed this report, stating that the song was being examined, and that if it did not meet the criteria, Kan would be given the opportunity to alter the lyrics or submit a new entry by 11 March.[59][60] However, Kan added that if it was asked to change the contents of the song, it would not do so, and be forced to withdraw from the contest. Miki Zohar, Culture and Sports Minister of Israel, called the intention of the EBU to reject the song "scandalous", and "called on the European Broadcasting Union to continue to act professionally and neutrally and not to let politics influence art";[61] he later expressed his support for the song to be altered in order to meet the criteria for the contest.[62]
On 22 February 2024, Kan published the lyrics of "October Rain".[63] Earlier that day, leaks by Israel Hayom and Ynet described the song as a ballad that builds up to a climax, referencing "the condition of Israeli civilians" in the 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel and also alluding to the Nova music festival massacre.[64][65] On 28 February, Ynet reported that the song that finished second in the internal selection, "Dance Forever", written by Golan alongside Ron Biton [he], May Sfadia, and Yinon Yahel, had also been rejected by the EBU,[66] On 3 March, Kan officially confirmed that it had submitted both "October Rain" and "Dance Forever" to the EBU for consideration, and that both had been rejected by the EBU in their current state. Despite previous statements, Kan ultimately asked the writers of both songs to "make the necessary adjustments" in order for them to be eligible,[54] and announced that the final intended entry, "Hurricane" (reported to be a revision of "October Rain" with changed lyrics), had been recorded later that day.[55][67] However, the song's writers were reportedly asked to rewrite its lyrics again,[68] and the final version was submitted two days later.[56] The EBU gave its approval for the song on 7 March.[69]
The humanitarian crisis resulting from Israeli military operations in the Gaza Strip during the war led to calls for the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) to exclude Israel from the 2024 contest, with human rights activists urging other countries to boycott the event.[70][71] Despite this, Israel ultimately appeared on the list of participants released by the EBU on 5 December 2023.[72] On 8 December, the EBU issued a statement maintaining that Kan "complies with all competition rules", allowing it to participate in 2024.[73][74] The situation sparked controversy in a number of participating countries:
Norway, Sweden, the Netherlands, Greece and Denmark – Representatives of Norwegian broadcaster NRK, Swedish broadcaster SVT, Dutch broadcaster AVROTROS and Greek broadcaster ERT stated that they would follow the EBU's decisions,[75][76][77][78][79] with NRK stating that it would not seek a "cultural boycott" of Israel not to "compromise [its] integrity"[80][81] and Danish broadcaster DR voicing its support for Israel's participation, citing the complexity and longstanding nature of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.[82][83] Demonstrations and petitions calling for a boycott occurred in Norway,[84][85] Sweden,[86] and Denmark.[87] In addition, in April 2024, three authors for NRK's annual Eurovision review refused to write it for 2024, demanding that the broadcaster pressure the EBU to exclude Israel from the contest.[88][89]
Iceland – On 9 December 2023, Stefán Eiríksson [is], the radio director of Icelandic broadcaster RÚV, stated that the country would still participate in the 2024 contest.[90] In response, the Association of Composers and Lyricists of Iceland (FTT) and activists of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, then joined by the Icelandic branch of OGAE, sent formal requests that RÚV withdraw from the event unless Israel was excluded "on the same grounds as Russia in the last competition", stressing on human rights violations on the Israeli part[91][92][93][94] RÚV then chose to hold its national competition, Söngvakeppnin2024, as usual, and then let the winner decide whether to participate in Eurovision.[95][96] Eventual Söngvakeppnin winner Hera Björk stated that she would participate in Eurovision prior to the final.[97] RÚV confirmed on 11 March that it would participate, with Hera Björk as its representative.[98] RÚV's commentator for the contest, Gísli Marteinn Baldursson, opted not to resume his role for 2024 in response to the EBU's "lack of reaction" to Israel's offensive in Gaza.[99]
Ireland – By mid-December 2023, Irish broadcaster RTÉ had received over 465 emails similarly urging it to boycott the event if Israel was permitted to compete, citing "the years of occupation and violence against Palestine"; RTÉ responded by stating that it had always approached the event as "a non-political contest designed to unite audiences and bring people together", arguing that no other broadcaster had expressed the intention to boycott it,[100] with TaoiseachLeo Varadkar and Irish head of delegation Michael Kealy opposing the calls.[101][102]
Finland – On 19 December 2023, Finnish broadcaster Yle stated that it had discussed the Israel–Hamas war situation with other Nordic broadcasters and monitored the EBU's stance, while also commenting that the war was not comparable to the Russian invasion of Ukraine.[103] The broadcaster decided to hold its Eurovision national final Uuden Musiikin Kilpailu (UMK) regardless of Finland's participation in Eurovision.[104][105] In January 2024, a petition was signed by Finnish music industry professionals demanding the broadcaster to withdraw or pressure for Israel to be excluded, arguing that the contest offered the country a platform to "polish its image",[106][107] with Yle responding that it would not oppose Israel's participation.[108]
Spain – Opposing earlier declarations by María Eizaguirre [es], head of communications of Spanish broadcaster RTVE, that it would follow the EBU's stance,[109] on 1 February 2024, Spanish left-wing party Podemos submitted a proposal to the Congress of Deputies in order for the government and RTVE to lobby against the inclusion of Israel in the contest and urge other countries to do the same,[110][111] with a contextual petition for withdrawal promoted within RTVE by Roberto Lakidain, representative of Podemos in the broadcaster's board of directors.[112]
Slovenia – Following public calls in the country for the exclusion of Israel, on 7 February 2024, Slovenian broadcaster RTVSLO asked the EBU to hold extensive discussions with its member broadcasters regarding Israeli participation,[113][114] ultimately receiving no response.[115]
Belgium – In early March 2024, Walloon minister of culture and media Bénédicte Linard [fr; nl] announced that she would formally request local broadcaster RTBF (responsible for Belgium's participation in 2024) to push for the exclusion of Israel from the contest, citing the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the exclusion of Russia in 2022; her Flemish counterpart Benjamin Dalle expressed support for the reasoning.[116][117] In mid-April, a letter was signed by workers of the Belgian cultural sector demanding that the EBU, RTBF and Flemish broadcaster VRT "take the warnings of the International Court of Justice seriously", "make a statement against the genocide" and bar Israel from competing; VRT commented that it followed the EBU's stance, while RTBF did not respond.[118]
United Kingdom – In protest against the EBU's approval of the Israeli entry, the organisers of the Eurovision Party London screening event at the Rio Cinema in Dalston, East London, decided to cancel its 2024 edition; this drew criticism from the British National Jewish Assembly, with the EBU's response reiterating that Eurovision "is not a contest between governments".[119]
On 9 April 2024, the EBU released a statement by deputy director-general Jean Philip De Tender addressing "targeted social media campaigns" against participating artists, reportedly over the insufficient pressure put on the union to exclude Israel. De Tender stated that the inclusion of a country in the contest "is the sole responsibility of the EBU's governing bodies and not that of the individual artists", condemning abuse or harassment directed at the performers while also defending the rationale whereby Kan had been allowed to take part;[146] this was reiterated by the contest's executive supervisor Martin Österdahl in an interview with Dagens industri on 27 April.[147][148] A FAQ page on Israel's participation was additionally created on the official website of the contest.[149]
Historical precedence
The EBU's decision to maintain Israel as a participant was compared to its decision to exclude Russia in 2022 following protests by several participating broadcasters – including the aforementioned NRK, SVT, AVROTROS, DR, RÚV and Yle – over the country's invasion of Ukraine, with some accusing the EBU of "hypocrisy" and exhibiting "double standards".[h]
Eden Golan visiting Israeli president Isaac Herzog and first lady Michal Herzog before leaving for Malmö
The Eurovision Song Contest 2024 took place at the Malmö Arena in Malmö, Sweden, and consisted of two semi-finals held on the respective dates of 7 and 9 May and the final on 11 May 2024. All nations with the exceptions of the host country and the "Big Five" (France, Germany, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom) were required to qualify from one of two semi-finals in order to compete in the final; the top ten countries from each semi-final progressed to the final. On 30 January 2024, an allocation draw was held to determine which of the two semi-finals, as well as which half of the show, each country would perform in; the EBU split up the competing countries into different pots based on voting patterns from previous contests, with countries with favourable voting histories put into the same pot.[155] At the request of Kan, Israel was allocated to the second semi-final as the rehearsal date for the first one coincides with Yom HaShoah;[156] the country was drawn to perform in the second half of the show.[157] The shows' producers then decided the running order for the semi-finals; Israel was set to perform in position 14.[158]
Eden Golan took part in technical rehearsals on 30 April and 3 May, followed by dress rehearsals on 8 and 9 May.[165] The staging of her performance of "Hurricane" at the contest is directed by Tzafir and Avichai Hacham, with five dancers accompanying the artist on stage and costumes designed by Alon Livne,[166][167][168] as well as the usage of a ring-shaped prop.[169] Livne claimed that the organisers explicitly instructed him against using any symbolism that might have political references to "the situation in Israel", rejecting a number of costume proposals.[168] However, the chosen costumes have been said to resemble bandages, evoking thoughts of a hurt, wounded, and healing nation.[170]
Protest actions
Golan's performances throughout the contest were met with booing,[171][172][173] prompting Kan to file complaints to the EBU.[172]
The EBU strove to keep any potentially politically coded messages out of the contest, but numerous other participants engaged in actions that were perceived as such, without directly criticising Israel's participation.[174][175] ACOD-VRT, the internal socialist trade union of Flemish broadcaster VRT, aired a statement before and after the broadcast of the second semi-final and the final, denouncing Israel's human rights violations and accusing the country of "destroying freedom of the press".[176]
Semi-final
Golan at the qualifiers press conference following the second semi-final.
Israel performed in position 14, following the entry from Estonia and before the entry from Norway.[158] At the end of the show, the country was announced as a qualifier for the final.
Final
Following the semi-final, Israel drew "producer's choice" for the final, meaning that the country would perform in the half decided by the contest's producers.[177] Israel was set to perform in position 6, following the entry from the Netherlands and before the entry from Lithuania; the Netherlands was later disqualified from the final, resulting in the entry from Luxembourg, which was set to perform in position 4, preceding Israel in the actual show.[178] Golan once again took part in dress rehearsals on 10 and 11 May before the final, including the jury final where the professional juries cast their final votes before the live show on 11 May. She performed a repeat of their semi-final performance during the final on 11 May. Israel placed fifth in the final, scoring 375 points; 323 points from the public televoting and 52 points from the juries.
Below is a breakdown of points awarded to and by Israel in the second semi-final and in the final. Voting during the three shows involved each country awarding sets of points from 1–8, 10 and 12: one from their professional jury and the other from televoting in the final vote, while the semi-final vote was based entirely on the vote of the public.[179] The Israeli jury consisted of Yaron Ashbel, Shlomit Dersso, Maya Opal Drukman, Kobi Marimi (who represented Israel in 2019), and May Sfadia.[180] In the second semi-final, Israel placed first with 194 points, receiving the maximum twelve points from Albania, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Italy, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Switzerland and the Rest of the World vote. In the final, Israel placed fifth with 375 points, receiving twelve points from Australia, Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, San Marino, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the Rest of the World in the televote.
Public votes for Israel were boosted by a campaign by Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Advertising Office, which featured Golan asking for support in French, Italian, Spanish, German, Czech, Latvian, Estonian, Albanian, Georgian and English. The campaign stated, "In light of the wave of hatred and Muslim demonstrations in Malmö, a counter-reaction by the silent majority is taking place. Europeans don't like what their eyes see."[181]
Over the course of the contest, Israel awarded its 12 points to Armenia in the second semi-final, and to Luxembourg in both the jury and televote in the final.[182][183]
Kan appointed Maya Alkulumbre [he] as its spokesperson to announce the Israeli jury's votes in the final.[184]
Each participating broadcaster assembles a five-member jury panel consisting of music industry professionals who are citizens of the country they represent. Each jury, and individual jury member, is required to meet a strict set of criteria regarding professional background, as well as diversity in gender and age. No member of a national jury was permitted to be related in any way to any of the competing acts in such a way that they cannot vote impartially and independently.[185] The individual rankings of each jury member as well as the nation's televoting results were released shortly after the grand final.
The following members comprised the Israeli jury:[180]
^Mishali, Gil (9 October 2023). "בצל המלחמה: צילומי 'הכוכב הבא' יידחו" [In the shadow of the war: the filming of "The Next Star" will be postponed]. Mako (in Hebrew). Retrieved 11 October 2023.
^Zaikaner, Avi (1 January 2024). "הכוכב הבא: אלו הם 14 המתמודדים שנכנסו לנבחרת!" [The Next Star: Here are the 14 contestants who entered the team!]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 1 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (3 January 2024). "גל כפרי הודח מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Gal Kafri has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 3 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (7 January 2024). "יהודה סעדו הודח מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Yehuda Saado has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 7 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (11 January 2024). "מיקה קרטיס הודחה מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Mika Kertis has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 11 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (15 January 2024). "עידו ברטל הודח מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Ido Bartal has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 15 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (17 January 2024). "מוריה אנג'ל הודחה מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Moria Angel has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (21 January 2024). "יונתן ביטון הודח מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Jonathan Bitton has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 21 January 2024.
^Dahan, Tal (22 January 2024). "אוראל רביד הודח מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Orel Ravid has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 22 January 2024.
^Dahan, Tal (26 January 2024). "אריק סיני הודח מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Arik Sinai has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 26 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (28 January 2024). "ליאן בירן הודחה מ'הכוכב הבא לאירוויזיון 2024'" [Lian Biran has been eliminated from "The Next Star for Eurovision 2024"]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 28 January 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (5 February 2024). "ישראל באירוויזיון: מחר ייבחר הנציג – ההצבעה נפתחה הערב!" [Israel in Eurovision: Tomorrow the representative will be chosen – the voting has been opened tonight!]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 5 February 2024.
^ abcdZaikaner, Avi (6 February 2024). "עדן גולן תייצג את ישראל באירוויזיון 2024" [Eden Golan will represent Israel at Eurovision 2024]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 6 February 2024.
^Zaikaner, Avi (16 January 2024). "השיר הישראלי לאירוויזיון 2024 ייבחר על ידי ועדה" [The Israeli song for Eurovision 2024 will be chosen by a committee]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 16 January 2024.
^Asraf Mizrahi, Dorit (21 February 2024). "ישראל לא תשתתף באירוויזיון 2024? הוויכוח על השיר הנבחר" [Israel will not participate in Eurovision 2024? The debate about the chosen song]. Kan Hadashot (in Hebrew). Kan. Retrieved 21 February 2024.
^Fisher, Dean (23 February 2024). "שר התרבות בעד השתתפות באירוויזיון: 'לא מתנגד לשינויים'" [The Minister of Culture supports Israel's participation: "Not opposed to cosmetic changes in the song"]. N12. Retrieved 24 February 2024.
^Asido, Shahar (19 November 2023). "מה יעלה בגורלה של ישראל באירוויזיון?" [What will happen to Israel in Eurovision?]. EuroMix (in Hebrew). Retrieved 20 November 2023.
^Edland, Gyrid Friis; Visker, Nora; Christensen, Siri B.; Hoen, Espen Sjølingstad (5 January 2024). "Demonstrasjon utenfor NRK før MGP-slipp: Ingen sier noe" [Demonstration outside NRK before release of MGP artists: "Nobody says anything"]. VG (in Norwegian Bokmål). Retrieved 8 January 2024.
^Valle, Marthe (6 December 2023). "Utesteng Israel fra Eurovision!" [Ban Israel from Eurovision!]. Opprop (in Norwegian Bokmål). Retrieved 20 January 2024.
^Davíðsdóttir, Erla María; Signýjardóttir, Ástrós (9 December 2023). "Stendur ekki til að sniðganga Eurovision" [Not going to boycott Eurovision]. ruv.is (in Icelandic). RÚV. Retrieved 12 December 2023.
^Kristjánsson, Alexander (23 December 2023). "FÁSES skorar á RÚV að senda ekki lag í Eurovision" [FÁSES challenges RÚV not to send a song to Eurovision]. ruv.is (in Icelandic). RÚV. Retrieved 24 December 2023.
^Valsson, Andri Yrkill (23 January 2024). "Ekki ljóst hvort Ísland taki þátt í Eurovision" [It is not clear whether Iceland will participate in Eurovision]. ruv.is (in Icelandic). RÚV. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
^Tjoflot, Eirin (13 January 2024). "Raudt-politikar kuppa MGP-sendinga" [Red Party politician takes over the MGP broadcast] (in Norwegian Nynorsk). NRK. Retrieved 14 January 2024.
^Sandholm Hellner, Annika (27 April 2024). "'Vi kommer att slå tillbaka rätt hårt'" [We will fight back quite hard]. Dagens industri (in Swedish). Retrieved 29 April 2024.
.jpg)
