The Scottish Green Party originated as the Scottish branch of the Ecology Party, founded in 1978 by Leslie Spoor.[11] The Ecology Party became the UKGreen Party and it remained a constituent party until 1990, when the Scottish Green Party became a separate entity.
The 1990 Highland Regional Council election gave the Greens their first ever councillor in the UK.[12] Roger (aka Rory) Winter, representing the Highland Green Party (Known in Scottish Gaelic as Uainich na Gàidhealtachd), was elected in Nairn. However, Cllr Winter broke away from the Greens in 1991 and continued his four-year term as an Independent Green Highlander.
First electoral successes (1999–2013)
Successful Scottish elections
In the first election to this Parliament, in 1999, the Scottish Green Party got one Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP) elected by proportional representation, Robin Harper, the UK's first elected Green parliamentarian.
In the 2003 Scottish Parliament election, the Scottish Greens added six new MSPs to their previous total.[13] The result was a surprise for the party.[14] Afterwards, Harper stood for election for First Minister, securing six votes.[15]
Co-convenor Robin Harper blamed the loss on spoiled ballot papers and the campaign focusing on larger parties.[18]
Supporters of the first SNP government.
Despite the loss of MSPs, the party gained influence with the new SNP government. On 11 May, the Greens signed an agreement with the Scottish National Party (SNP), which meant that the Greens voted for Alex Salmond as First Minister and supported his initial Ministerial appointments.[19][20] In return, the SNP backed a climate change bill as an early measure and promised to legislate against ship-to-ship oil transfers in the Firth of Forth. The SNP also agreed to nominate Patrick Harvie, one of the Green MSPs, to convene the Scottish Parliament Committee on Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change.
Differences, primarily over transport policy, were cited for the limited nature of the agreement.[19] But they left open the door to further negotiations should the Scottish Liberal Democrats join the First Salmond government.
Given the present situation that (the SNP) are going to be forming a minority government, it really didn't seem to make sense for us to tie ourselves closely into confidence and supply or into coalition, because we have serious reservations about many SNP policies, particularly their transport policies
During the election, co-convenor Shiona Baird lost her seat, and did not re-stand for election as co-convenor. She was replaced by then Edinburgh councillor Alison Johnstone in November 2007.[21]
Robin Harper and Johnstone did not seek re-election in 2008 as co-convenor. While Harvie was the sole nominee for the male co-convenor, there was 3 candidates for female co-convenor: former MSP Eleanor Scott, Glasgow councillor Nina Baker and Edinburgh councillor Maggie Chapman.[22] The role of female co-convenor was won by Scott.[23][24]
During the 2009 Scottish budget process, the Scottish Greens demanded an £1 billion home insulation programme over 10 years.[25] The SNP Scottish Government offered £22 million for a 'pilot' project. The party decided this compromise was not acceptable.
On 28 January 2009, the two Green MSPs were instrumental in the defeat of the Government's budget.[26] The move surprised some commentators, whose leadership had until this point been marked with increased cooperation with the SNP government.[27]
A slightly amended version of the budget was passed easily the following week with the support of other parties.[28]
2011 Scottish parliament election
At the party's 2010 conference, Robin Harper announced that he would not seek re-election in the 2011 Scottish Parliament election.[29][30] The party's election campaign was launched with a focus on investment into public services paid for by tax raises.[31][32] In the end, the party only elected 2 MSPs in the 2011.[33]
Independence referendum and rapid growth (2014–2019)
2014 Independence referendum
In November 2013, Edinburgh councillor Maggie Chapman succeeded Glasgow councillor Martha Wardrop as the party's female co-convenor after she did not seek re-election, while Patrick Harvie was re-elected.[35][36]
The party's own campaign of 'Green Yes' launched in October 2013, and advocated that only independence could deliver radical change, with Harvie also arguing that the party's vision of independence was progressive, and explicitly not nationalistic.[41][42] He also argued that devolution did not go far enough to tackle issues important to Scots like austerity.[43]
For me, it's got nothing to do with flags, or 300 years of history; it's about the future. And I think that the best way [...] of changing Scotland
However, some in the party were opposed to independence, including former convenor Robin Harper who said that he would "absolutely vote No".[44]
Membership before and after independence referendum[45][46]
Year
Membership
2013
1,178
2014
7,800
2015
9,000
After the independence referendum, the Scottish Greens experienced a massive surge in membership, including future co-leader Lorna Slater.[47][48][49] The party claimed that, for a period in the day after the referendum, it gained a member every 15 seconds.[50]
The party's then co-convenors, Harvie and Chapman were chosen by the party to serve as its representatives on the post-referendum Smith Commission.[51][52] The party argued that full powers on income tax, the bulk of welfare policy, energy, transport, employment law and human rights law should be transferred to Holyrood.[53]
2016 Scottish Parliament election and Brexit
In 2015, Maggie Chapman was challenged as co-convenor by activist Zara Kitson in the party's internal elections.[54] The election was notable as it was the first time an incumbent co-convenor faced a serious challenge, all to date had been re-elected as the sole nominees. Chapman was re-elected.
In the leadup to the 2016 Scottish Parliament election, the party campaigned with a focus on tax-rises for the rich, with co-convenor Patrick Harvie saying it would be "agenda item one" in any post-election talks with the SNP.[55][56] The party's selection process of co-convenor Maggie Chapman as lead candidate in the North East Scotland region for the 2016 election attracted controversy.[57][58][59]
In the 2016 Scottish Parliament election, the party won 6 more seats, its best result since 2003.[60] The result pushed the party ahead of the Scottish Liberal Democrats in seat numbers, making it the fourth-largest party for the first time.[61] The Scottish Greens also elected the youngest MSP ever, Ross Greer at the age of 21.[62]
In February 2015, the party announced that it would field candidates in 32 seats for the 2015 United Kingdom general election with 40% of their candidates being women.[66] In 2017 the party generated some controversy by standing only 3 candidates at the general election.[67] In the 2019 general election they contested significantly more seats in 22 constituencies. They failed to win any seats and lost their deposit in every contest.
After two months of negotiations, on 20 August 2021, the Scottish Greens announced a new power-sharing agreement with the SNPScottish Government.[73][74][75] While not an official coalition, for the first time in Scottish and UK history it offered the Greens two ministerial posts.[76][77][78] The agreement saw both parties pledge for a second referendum on Scottish independence, an increase investment in active travel and public transport, enhancing tenants rights, a ten-year £500m Just Transition and establishing a National Care Service.[79][80] The agreement was approved by 83% of Scottish Green members, and secured a two-thirds majority vote of the party's National Council.[81] This was required under the party's constitution for the agreement to be ratified.
Academic Professor Nicola McEwen suggested that the agreement "sometimes pushes [the SNP] further" particularly on climate, social and fair work policy.[82] She also argues that the two parties had already converged on many issues over the preceding decade. However, critics and supporters of the party agreed that the agreement had allowed the party to have a lot of influence on the Scottish government.[83][84]
After the election of Humza Yousaf as Leader of the Scottish National Party, the Scottish Green Party National Council unanimously voted to direct its MSPs to vote for Yousaf to become First Minister and continue their power-sharing agreement.[85][86] During the leadership campaign, the party had suggested it would not support a government led by the other candidates.[87][88] The party's co-leaders served as ministers in the first Yousaf government from August 2021 to April 2024.
On 3 August 2023, Robin Harper, the party's first MSP resigned, claiming the party had 'lost the plot'. Harper announced he would vote Labour in the 2024 UK general election.[90] Nonetheless, the party also enjoyed an unprecedented level of support.[91]
Following the announcement by Màiri McAllan that the Scottish Government's legally binding target to see a 75% percent reduction in emissions by 2030 would not be achieved and was to be scrapped, an extraordinary general meeting was called by Scottish Green Party members to discuss the future of the agreement. On the 25th April 2024, following a meeting at Bute House, it was decided that the power sharing agreement would come to an end.[100][101]
Within days of the Scottish independence referendum being held, the membership swelled to more than 5,000.[45] Launching its manifesto for the 2015 UK general election, the Scottish Greens stated a membership of over 8,500.[104] By October 2015 the party were holding their biggest ever conference, with their membership standing at more than 9,000.[46] In mid-2021 it had fallen back somewhat, reported as standing at 7,500.[105] In April 2023, the number of members had risen to 7,646.[2]
Conferences
The Scottish Greens hold conferences every Spring and Autumn, where members from throughout Scotland attend to deal with all the business of the party, with members voting on conference motions and policy motions.
Internal party bodies
There are two key bodies which steer the party between conferences: party council and the national executive. The party council can, with some exceptions, act as a more frequent conference on issues that appear outside conference season. The national executive oversees the day-to-day administration of party activities.
The party has a Conduct and Complaints Committee. In May 2024, it expelled thirteen members after a disciplinary investigation.[106][107] Those expelled were accused of breaching the party's code of conduct by signing the eight-point Scottish Green Declaration For Women's Sex-Based Rights that asserted that "sex is a biological reality", of which it was complained made the party less safe for transgender and non-binary members.[108][106] The party has stated that "trans-exclusionary individuals of any kind are not welcome as members".[106]
Branches
The party is made up of branches, who usually cover one or more local authority areas, and meet on a regular basis.
Representation groups
The Scottish Greens have six self-organised representation groups:[109]
Co-leader Patrick Harvie has described the party's ideals as:[112]
Of a liveable planet.
Of justice, equality and dignity for all people.
Of Scotland's right to decide its own future – not because of attachment to one flag or another, but because of a clear, compelling vision of what a Green Scotland could be.
Four principles
According to the party's website, the Scottish Greens are committed to forming a sustainable society and are guided by four interconnected principles:
Ecology: "Our environment is the basis upon which every society is formed. Whenever we damage our environment, we damage ourselves. Respect for our environment is therefore essential".
Equality: "A society that is not socially and economically just cannot be sustainable. Only when released from immediate poverty can individuals be expected to take responsibility for wider issues. Our society must be founded on cooperation and respect. We campaign hard against discrimination on grounds of gender, race, sexuality, disability, age or religion".
Radical democracy: "Politics is too often conducted in a polarised, confrontational atmosphere and in a situation remote from those that it affects. We must develop decentralised, participative systems that encourage individuals to control the decisions that affect their own lives".
Peace and nonviolence: "Violence at all levels of human interaction must be rejected and succeeded by relations characterised by flexibility, respect and fairness".
The party claims that, taken together, these principles give the party a holistic view that is in common with all green parties around the world.[113]
Factions
Eco-socialism
There are internal factions which seek to transform the party's ideology to be eco-socialist.[114][115] In the party's 2019 internal elections, the Green Futures Group ran a slate of candidates on a platform of a Green New Deal, eco-socialism and independence.[116] The group's candidates were all elected and hold key positions in the party as of 2019.[117] In 2015, future MSP and then co-convenor Maggie Chapman, former MSP Mark Ballard and influential member Peter McColl were reported to be part of a "leftist grouping inside the Greens".[57] McColl argued that Chapman's election and subsequent role as lead candidate in the 2014 European Parliament election marked an increased socialist influence on the party.[118] In 2023, the Scottish Green Party Trade Union Group called the party's parliamentary group a "group of ecosocialist MSPs in their own right."[119]
There are many of us who are socialists, is the party as a whole socialist? I'd like to say yes, but I don't know if I can…
In 2021, the party's conference backed a motion calling for the party to work "towards building a democratic ecosocialist system", which was taken by some internal groups, such as the Scottish Young Greens as the party backing eco-socialism.[121][122] The party's critics on the Labour left like Coll McCail and Finn Smyth claim that it has taken a neo-liberal turn in office and is simply maintaining the status-quo by reneging on commitments like the establishment of a government owned energy company.[122]Radical Independence Campaign co-founder Cat Boyd noted that while the party had been "a consistent ally of the radical left" she was concerned that may end as the party got closer to power due to "the temptations of 'pragmatic' coalition government".[123]
McCail and Smyth's criticism was engaged with by the party. Green MSP Ross Greer who co-authored the party's power-sharing agreement with the SNPScottish Government argued that they had identified the wrong problem, and that the Government's lacking capital borrowing powers was what forced the end of the policies they discussed.[124]
After the 2021 Scottish Parliament election, in which she was elected as a MSP, Chapman argued that the left had "won the Scottish Green Party".[125] She argued the election was the first which the party "run a campaign on the basis of policies rather than personalities or tactical voting messages" and that those policies emphasised social justice and climate justice.
The party's 2019 manifesto included pledges to implement a green new deal to tackle climate change and for future investment, the introduction of a universal basic income, the phasing in of a four-day week, support for rent controls and treating drug use as a health issue rather than a crime.[129]
Climate change
The party favours strong action to combat climate change, including phasing out single-use plastic, the creation of more Low Emission Zones in cities and a ban on the sale of new petrol cars, diesel cars and fossil fuel boilers.[130] The party also seeks "ambitious" climate action, and in 2019 abstained on the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill claiming it was not "anywhere near meaningful action to address the climate emergency".[131] However, the BBC News journalist Philip Sim argued in 2021 that since then the party position has shifted to "hitting these [carbon emissions reduction targets] than stretching them".[132]
In government, the party's ministers announced a ban on new waste incinerators and a new biodiversity strategy.[133]
Transport
The Greens are against plans to dual the A9 and the A96, arguing that the plans are incompatible with climate commitments.[134] Instead, the party advocates for the expansion of Scotland's railway network, such as a tunnel across the Forth constructed between Leith and Kirkcaldy, an aim to connect every town with more than 5,000 people to the railway network and to completely electrify the Scottish network by 2030.[135]
The Scottish Greens also supported the nationalisation of ScotRail and Caledonian Sleeper, and advocates for "the whole of Scotland's railways – both track and train – to be brought into public ownership".[136][137][138] The party, as part of its co-operation agreement with the Scottish Government scrapped peak-time rail fares for at least one year.[139]
The party also supports a wider nationalisation of all rail, bus and ferry companies, alongside further investment in walking, wheeling and cycling.[140]
Scottish independence
It is the second largest party to both support Scottish independence and have representation in the Scottish Parliament. At the party's 2005 conference, a motion passed to support Scottish independence.[141]
The Scottish Green Party supports Scotland having its own currency if it were to become an independent country. The party has said this would be in order to establish full economic independence, rather than being tied to the pound sterling.[142][143][144]
However, in an interview at the party's 2023 autumn conference, co-leader Lorna Slater suggested that independence was not a "red line" for any future power-sharing deals with Scottish Labour, re-affirming similar comments during the independence referendum.[146]
LGBT+ rights
The party has campaigned strongly for LGBT rights, with the party publishing a specific LGBT+ manifesto co-produced with its LGBT wing.[147] The party supports gender self-identification, banning conversion therapy, improving LGBT+ inclusive education and improving transgender healthcare.[148] The party has also campaigned to get more non-binary people into politics, and voted to 'suspend ties' with the Green Party of England and Wales due to transphobia concerns.[149][150]
We will only vote for the SNP's new Leader to become First Minister if... they agree that trans rights are human rights. [...] These are fundamental issues for us. They are non-negotiable.
Co-leader Lorna Slater, speaking at the party's 2023 Spring Conference.[151]
The party was the only party to support same-sex civil partnerships upon its entry to the Scottish Parliament in 1999.[152] In 2003, the party's MSP Patrick Harvie introduced a bill to allow civil partnerships in Scotland.[153] The bill failed, but was key to creating the debate on the topic which let to its passing at Westminster.[154]
The Scottish Greens have also firmly supported reforms to the Gender Recognition Act 2004. The party's MSP Andy Wightman, and later, the party's first MSP Robin Harper both left the party over the policy.[90][155] Despite this, the party remained committed to the policy, arguing that "...human rights, including the rights of trans people, are at the core of our vision and have been since our party was founded over 30 years ago". The party opposed the UK Government's veto of the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill.[156]
The Scottish Greens is led by a six-person leadership team. This is made up of the co-leaders of the party, the co-chairs of the national executive of the party and the co-convenors of the party council.
The political leadership roles are generally held by a present or aspiring elected politician, while internal leadership is held by a mixture of ordinary members and aspiring or elected politicians.
Political leadership
Alongside many other green parties, the Scottish Greens initially shunned the idea of a singular leader, despite key party figures like Robin Harper commenting that it must "have an official Leader and face to represent it if it is to sustain political effectiveness."[157][158][30] Increasingly, during Patrick Harvie's tenure as co-convenor, the role became more like a traditional party leader, as his profile as an MSP tended to overshadow his fellow co-convenor.[120][159][160] In 2019, as a part of internal party reforms, the role of two co-leaders was introduced, with Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater elected as inaugural co-leaders.[70] A maximum of one of the co-leaders may identify as a man.
Unlike party leaders in most other political parties, the Scottish Greens' co-leaders are only elected for two year terms, after which they may seek re-election.[161] Generally, incumbents are returned without opposition, but the inaugural co-leadership election,[a] and 2015 co-convenorship election were contested.[54]
The other four members of the party's leadership team are drawn from its national council and executive. They serve for two year terms, and are elected by a ballot of party members.
Party Council
Between conferences, the Party Council provides the forum for strategic decisions, policy discussions, oversight and branch coordination. The council is composed of two delegates from branches, usually branch co-convenors, representative and special interest groups. Its decisions can only be overridden by a party conference or AGM.
The council is currently led by council co-convenors Laura Moodie and Kate Nevens.
Party Executive Committee
The National Executive oversees the day-to-day administration of the party. It is led by two co-chairs, directly elected by party members, and who manage the party staff and its volunteer-led National Committees which focus on specific party functions like policy development or engagement with the European Greens. Its decisions may be overridden by the party council or conference.
It is presently chaired by Ross Greer and Carolynn Scrimgeour, who was co-opted after the resignation of Ellie Gomersall in December 2023.[162] This committee also oversees the work of the elected National Committees; Finance & Fundraising, Elections & Campaigns, Policy, Membership and International.
John Finnie for Highlands and Islands. Finnie was elected Green within this region in May 2016, having previously been SNP then Independent. Stood down in 2021.
Robin Harper for the Lothians. Harper was the first elected Green parliamentarian in the UK and was the party's convener from the time of that position's creation in 1999 until 2002. He later served as one of its co-conveners from 2004 to 2008.
Eleanor Scott for the Highlands and Islands. Scott was party convener from 2002 to 2004, and a co-convener of the party from 2008 to 2011.
Andy Wightman was an MSP for the Lothian region 2016 to 2021. He was elected for the party in the 2016 election, but left in December 2020 after facing possible complaints and disciplinary action for the way he intended to vote on an amendment to the Forensic Medical Services (Victims of Sexual Offences) (Scotland) Bill. He had planned to vote against the party and for the amendment, in conflict with the party's policy on trans rights. He stated in his resignation letter that he felt the party had an "alienating and provocative" stance on trans rights.[165][166]
Prior to the 2007 elections, the Party had only ever elected one councillor at local level: in May 1990, Roger (aka Rory) Winter, representing the Highland Green Party (Uainich na Gàidhealtachd), was elected in Nairn as Scotland's first Green regional councillor to the then Highland Regional Council. Cllr Winter broke away from the Greens in 1991 and continued his four-year term as an Independent Green Highlander.
The party made its first major breakthroughs at council level in the 2007 local elections, electing eight councillors between Glasgow City and the City of Edinburgh Councils.
In the 2012 local elections, this was increased to 14. The party elected councillors for the first time to Aberdeenshire, Stirling & Midlothian Councils.
At the 2017 local elections, the party returned a record 19 councillors, including elected councillors to Orkney Islands Council for the first time. However, the party lost its sole councillor on Midlothian Council.
The 2022 local elections saw another record number of Green councillors elected. Thirty five candidates gained seats across 13 local authorities, an increase of 16.[170] This included the first ever Green councillors in North Lanarkshire, South Lanarkshire, Argyll & Bute, Clackmannanshire, Shetland, East Lothian, Moray and the Scottish Borders.[171][172] In March 2024, the party won its first ever by-election, electing Seonad Hoy as a councillor in Hillhead ward in Glasgow.[99]
Electoral performance
Vote share represents the party's share in Scotland rather than the UK at large.
^"Scottish Independence"(PDF). Scottish Greens. November 2012. Archived from the original(PDF) on 28 March 2014. Retrieved 12 December 2019. A hereditary monarchy is incompatible with Green principles of democracy, equality and fairness. We favour an elected Head of State.
^Dennison, James (2017). The Greens in British politics: protest, anti-austerity and the divided left. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. p. 50. ISBN978-3-319-42672-3.
^Dennison, James (2017). The Greens in British politics: protest, anti-austerity and the divided left. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 50–51. ISBN978-3-319-42672-3.
^ abDennison, James (2017). The Greens in British politics: protest, anti-austerity and the divided left. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. pp.51. ISBN978-3-319-42672-3.
^"Scottish Independence"(PDF). Scottish Greens. November 2012. Archived from the original(PDF) on 28 March 2014. Retrieved 12 December 2019. A hereditary monarchy is incompatible with Green principles of democracy, equality and fairness. We favour an elected Head of State.
^Scotland Can Be A Global CitizenArchived 18 January 2017 at the Wayback Machine. 'A nuclear-free Scotland. Scotland's opposition to the Trident nuclear weapons system is well-established and we are proud to be at the forefront of efforts to disband this obscene Cold War relic. We would pursue every possible avenue to pressure Westminster into getting rid of the nuclear weapons stored on the Clyde. We would explore options such as: issuing guidance to Police Scotland not to enforce charges against nonviolent activists involved in protests against the Faslane base and shipments of nuclear weapons on Scottish roads; amending the Marine Scotland Act to include a ban on the movement of nuclear weapons through Scottish waters; and ending government support for businesses involved in the supply chain for Trident'. Scottish Green Party (official website)Archived 15 March 2016 at the Wayback Machine. Retrieved 12 January 2017.