Meehan moved to Manhattan at age 24, and worked at The New Yorker's "Talk of the Town".[7]
In 1972, Meehan was approached by Martin Charnin to work on a musical based on the comic strip Little Orphan Annie.[4] At first, Meehan was skeptical to accept the offer, but eventually accepted the offer after reading the strip.[6] Meehan wrote Annie with Charles Strouse, who wrote the music, and Martin Charnin who directed and wrote the lyrics.[8] The production took five years to get to Broadway, but after opening in 1977 ran for 2,377 performances.[6]
In addition, Meehan was a long-time contributor of humor to The New Yorker, including the famous short story "Yma Dream"; an Emmy Award-winning writer of television comedy; and a collaborator on a number of screenplays, including Mel Brooks' Spaceballs; a remake of To Be or Not to Be; and the family drama One Magic Christmas.[11] Meehan went on to work with Brooks on other projects on Broadway, including The Producers, based on the 1967 film. The show became a Broadway hit that dominated the 2001 Tony Awards and ran for more than 2,500 performances.[6]
Meehan held the distinction of being the only writer to have written three Broadway shows that ran for more than 2,000 performances.[19] Reflecting on his work in an interview with The New York Observer in 1999, Meehan said "I wrote stories that were serious, very somber, trying to be in the style of William Faulkner. My career has always been that every time I try something really serious, it's no good, but if I try to be funny, then it works".[20]
Death
Meehan died from cancer at his home in Manhattan on August 21, 2017, one week after his 88th birthday.[21][6] Five months prior to his death, Meehan had undergone surgery, which later caused his health to deteriorate.[22]
Meehan was survived by two children from his first marriage with Karen Meehan, which ended in divorce, and three other children with Carolyn Wagstaff Capstick, whom he married in 1988 and with whom he remained until his death.[6]
Mel Brooks memorialized Meehan, tweeting "I'll miss his sweetness & talent. We have all lost a giant of the theatre."[23]
In 2023 his archives were donated to The New York Public Library for the Performing Arts' Billy Rose Theatre Division.[24]